Homeownership vs. Renting Apartment: Weighing Pros & Cons

12/09/2017 Author: Payleaf Team

Many savvy millennials are transitioning from renting an apartment to owning a home.  Are you looking for a quick checklist to see if you’re ready for homeownership?  Here is an overview of the pros and cons of renting an apartment versus owning a home.

renting apartment vs homeownership


We asked millennials who are currently renting about the pros and cons of their living situation.  We also asked apartment managers who rent to millennials about the challenges and benefits of apartment living.  Both groups shared their insights with us.  Here are some of the key points they told us.


You sign a lease for a short duration of time, anywhere from 6 months to 1 year, sometimes 2 years, which means that afterwards, you have the freedom go somewhere else. Finances are less likely to tie you down.

You are not responsible for the costly repairs to things such as roofs, water heaters, etc.

The government does not require you to pay property tax.

You may not have to pay for certain utilities, depending on your lease arrangement.

Often you are not responsible for lawn care. No yard work!  This article suggests that for millennials, who have busy schedules, the prospect of not having to take care of a lawn is a major plus.


If you sublet during your lease, you are responsible for any damage that the person subletting creates.

Your rent payments do not gain you equity. Your rent money just disappears, and you gain nothing in return.

You do not always get to choose your neighbors. People come and go.

You will have people living above, below and to either side of you.

There may be people you don’t know passed out, sleeping in the common areas of your apartment.  There are a myriad of stories about this curious phenomenon, from homeless people sleeping in hallways, to your drunk neighbor mistaking your door for his, and falling asleep leaning against your door after trying to fit his keys in your lock.  In the latter example, renters have been on the outside and inside when this has happened.  Both situations are equally startling.

You have the option to buy renter’s insurance.  You could lose all of your stuff, including beloved pets, if someone else carelessly forgets to turn their space heater off before they leave the building.  Additionally, you cannot control whether or not a property has a security system, and if it does, how it is used.


the pride of homeownership


We also asked millennials who own their first home, as well as those who have sold their first home and purchased their second, about the challenges and advantages to homeownership.  Additionally, we talked with baby boomers who have decades of experience in home ownership to weigh in and give us the pros and cons.  Here is a list of what they told us.


The value of your house increases over time, so if you are in the same house for decades, you can sell your house for more than the purchase price, thus making a profit on the sale.

Homes are more family friendly if you plan to have little ones running about.

You may have as many animals as you could possibly want, provided you take care of them.

The pride of ownership. Unquantifiable, but important! You own your own castle.   

Saw holes in your roof, hang weird artifacts from strange places, put graffiti on the walls, or decorate just like your mother did.  It’s your stuff so who can stop you?

You can make as much noise as you like, provided your neighbors across the street do not care. You could finally start that garage band you’ve always dreamed about!


If something breaks, you must be ready to put out the cash, or fix it yourself.

There may be an HOA, or home-owners association, to which you may be required to pay yearly fees for general maintenance, security or repairs in common areas.  Additionally, your presence at HOA meetings may be required for voting purposes.   

You will need homeowners insurance to cover replacement of belongings and large repairs after a disaster, such as a new roof after a hail storm.  Or new flooring after a major plumbing catastrophe.

If you do not have enough cash to purchase the house in full, you need to take out a mortgage loan and you will need to cover your mortgage payments with insurance.  Because you are taking out a mortgage loan, you will need PMI, or private mortgage insurance.  PMI is required if you pay less than 20% of the total price of the home in the downpayment.  In addition to monthly mortgage payments, there will be a required monthly PMI fee.

Payleaf get started with homeownership


In summary, your decision to own a home after renting an apartment should take into account both the pros and the cons of each.  If you are planning to own a home, you may want to consider some of the online tools available to you.  One of these tools is Payleaf, which provides a highly accurate homeownership cost calculator, as well as an online budget tracking tool.  Go to Payleaf.com to find out how much purchasing and maintaining your home will cost per month and learn how Payleaf can help track your savings over time as you approach your savings goal for your downpayment.  


LEAVE A REPLY Your email address will not be published. All fields are required

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


Frequently Asked Questions

Q: How does Payleaf work? A: Payleaf exists to help people earn and save for the important things in life.  Payleaf helps you create a...

Read More Leave a Comment

The Power of Enlistment to Accomplish Financial Goals

If you seek a positive and impactful experience, whether at work, home, or within your community, you should consider the power of...

Read More Leave a Comment

Travel: what vacation really means, and how you can maximize it

There is one finite commodity that we all possess, and it is not money.  It is not our level of education.  It is not our net worth.  It...

Read More Leave a Comment

Fixer upper vs. Move in ready (do you see yourself living there)

Many first time home buyers are weighing their options as the housing market surges with new health and abundance.  How do these potential...

Read More Leave a Comment

Expensive vs. Going on the cheap (or other things you could do with the wedding budget)

If you or someone you know is planning a wedding, congratulations!  This is an exciting time, when two individuals commit to a lifelong...

Read More Leave a Comment

Must haves for new parents: what you will need before (during) and after you have a baby

Experienced and established parents shared their stories and advice on ways to prepare for parenthood and save money in the...

Read More Leave a Comment

What If The Only Way to Save Is When I Can’t See It

Recent studies cite that emotions often trigger both spending and saving. We squirrel money away because we either have great anticipation...

Read More Leave a Comment

Few People Know How Much It Costs to Have a Baby

Good things that come in small packages are often the most expensive things, and babies are no exception. Ask any second-time parent and...

Read More Leave a Comment

Why Americans Aren’t Saving

Are you one of the estimated 60 percent of Americans who either has no savings at all or whose emergency cash amounts to less than $1,000?...

Read More Leave a Comment